Everton gifted Bournemouth victory and a passage into the FA Cup fifth round, with the result making it the last fixture in the competition at Goodison Park.
The Toffees have hosted matches at this famous venue since 1892, but defeat meant their next home FA Cup fixture will come at their new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock, where the Toffees are scheduled to move for the start of next season.
The five-time winners were the architects of their own downfall for the two goals they conceded, with defender James Tarkowski suffering a nightmare as his errors contributed to both Bournemouth’s first-half strikes.
The Blues skipper first mistimed a sliding tackle on Antoine Semenyo inside the box midway through the first half and the Bournemouth forward climbed off the turf before despatching an emphatic penalty past Jordan Pickford.
Ghana international Semenyo was a constant nuisance for the Everton backline and also screwed another effort wide, while a strike from the angle was blocked by Jarrad Branthwaite.
Bournemouth doubled their lead two minutes before half-time when Tarkowski gave the ball away and then failed to make a challenge on Daniel Jebbison, who bundled in from close range.
David Moyes’ men were much improved in the second half and incredibly hit the woodwork three times, but could not find a way past visiting keeper Kepa Arrizabalaga.
Deadline-day signing Carlos Alcaraz came off the bench for Everton and curled a 25-yard free-kick against the post, while Jake O’Brien’s header and Jack Harrison’s cross both came crashing off the other upright.
Impressive Cherries maintain fine form
Andoni Iraola has performed a sterling job since taking over at Bournemouth in 2023 and led the south coast club to seventh in the Premier League this season.
On Saturday, they needed a helping hand from the opposition but were clinical when the chances were presented to them in the opening period.
Semenyo set them on their way in the 23rd minute with a confident penalty after being hacked down by the hapless Tarkowski, with sheer power beating Pickford despite the England international diving the right way.
Fellow forward Jebbison was in the right place at the right time to net the second, with Tarkowski again punished after attempting to play out from the back but sending a pass straight to a Bournemouth player.
The Cherries had the better early chances and could have scored in the opening 10 seconds – like Everton had done here against Leicester in their previous Premier League game – but Marcus Tavernier’s effort was well blocked by Tarkowski.
Justin Kluivert came off the bench after the hour mark and almost scored with his first touch, having a curling strike pushed away by Pickford, while the Everton goalkeeper then brilliantly kept out Dango Ouattara’s thumping strike.
But victory for Bournemouth meant they beat Everton for the first time in the FA Cup after previous defeats in 1937 and 2016.
“A great result for us,” said Iraola. “Two different halves. First half we were better. Second half they pushed us more and we were defending more. Also we played the worst kind of football but we defended well.
“[Last season in the fifth round] we played against Leicester – they scored an amazing goal in extra time – and we couldn’t play the quarter-finals. Let’s see if we can go one step more. Playing in an FA Cup quarter-final would sound nice.
“It is still too early [to think about winning the FA Cup]. There will still be 15 other teams. Let’s see what the draw says.”
Antoine Semenyo scored his ninth goal of the season for Bournemouth
